In an era where we can choose from 50+ varieties of ketchup, binge-watch a dozen streaming platforms, or swipe through a seemingly endless sea of dating prospects, we would surely love to think that we are the ones who are in control. A platter of options and presumed ‘free will’, right? Well, not really! Our choices more often than not in today’s times are being dictated by invisible hands—algorithms, social conditioning, and cognitive biases—all of which make us puppets in a play we didn’t even choose to audition for.
Need another relatable example? Picture this: You walk into a coffee shop, determined to grab a simple cup of black coffee. But as soon as you step inside, you’re hit with a wall of options—espresso, Americano, macchiato, oat milk latte, extra foam, double shot, caramel drizzle. By the time you order, you’ve either chosen something completely different or, worse, stood there like a fish out of water while the barista impatiently taps their fingers. Congratulations, you’ve just fallen into the illusion of choice.
We live in an age where choices are everywhere, giving us the sense that we are in control. We live in a bubble which is governed by the paradox of choice, with the best minds of the world determined to not let you break free— while at least you try to!
Simple, logical thought – More choices = more freedom. Might have been true a few generations before us, when there were literally not enough choices. However, with the plethora of options we have and at the convenience that we do - the more options we have, the more miserable we are becoming. Ever stood in the supermarket aisle, staring at 45 brands of Yoghurt, and felt completely overwhelmed? That’s a classic case of ‘decision fatigue’ —a real phenomenon where an excess of choices leads to anxiety and confusion rather than empowerment.
Even in the case of shopping. You go to buy a simple T-shirt and suddenly find yourself comparing fabric blends, patterns, and neck cuts until you’re being sucked into the quick sand of indecision. By the time you finally click ‘buy,’ you’re so mentally drained that you just tend to add it to your Wishlist and thereby putting off the decision for a later time! Another epic case of exhaustion by choice overload.
Take your mind back to how you pick a movie on Netflix. Ever noticed how it suggests movies eerily similar to what you just watched? That’s not you making a choice; that’s an algorithm gently nudging you down a predictable path, ensuring you stay hooked. You scroll for 30 minutes, overwhelmed by endless categories—thrillers, sci-fi thrillers, psychological sci-fi thrillers, rom-coms and more. Eventually, you give up and just end up rewatching Friends or Suits for the umpteenth time (comfort food). It’s not freedom; it’s exhaustion.
The same goes for social media filter bubbles, where you only see content that reinforces your existing beliefs. You think you’re well-informed, but in reality, you’re just living in a highly curated echo chamber. Ever wonder why the ads on your phone seem to know you better than your best friend? That’s because they do. Algorithms track your habits, likes, and even how long you linger on a particular post. Your social media feed, your shopping recommendations, even your Spotify playlist—none of it is random. It’s all carefully curated to nudge you in a specific direction.
Netflix isn’t giving you suggestions; it’s subtly dictating your choices. Amazon isn’t helping you find the best product; it’s guiding you toward what it wants to sell. You think you’re making an independent decision, but you’re just playing into a well-designed trap.
Nowhere is this phenomenon more apparent than in modern dating. Apps like Tinder and Bumble present an infinite scroll of potential partners. Sounds great, right? Wrong. Instead of increasing satisfaction, it creates a ‘grass is greener’ mindset—always swiping for someone better, even if you’ve already met someone wonderful. The more choices we have, the harder it becomes to commit to any of them.
Omnipresent algorithms - digital puppeteers pulling our strings, tracking everything from our shopping habits to how long we hover over a meme pages. Based on this, they serve up curated content that keeps you in your comfort zone while making you believe you’re exploring freely.
Even beyond technology, society has been influencing our choices long before algorithms were a thing. From childhood, we are subtly nudged toward certain careers, lifestyles, and belief systems. If you grew up in a family of doctors, was your decision to go to med school truly yours? Or was it a well-manicured path paved long before you ever questioned it?
Consider the case of the ‘good life’ template: go to college, get a stable job, buy a house, get married, retire. This blueprint is so ingrained in us that deviating from it feels rebellious. Yet, how many of these decisions were truly ours, uninfluenced by parental expectations, cultural norms, or peer pressure?
Marketing fuels this illusion. Brands don’t just sell products; they sell aspirations. You don’t buy a Rolex because you need to tell time—you buy it because it signals success. You don’t pick a designer handbag because it’s practical—you pick it because it projects status. Why settle for an affordable car when a slightly costlier one makes you look more accomplished? Our decisions are less about what we need and more about how we want to be perceived. Before we know it, we are making choices that align more with status signalling than our personal needs.
Another crazy trap these days comes in the form of ‘gut feeling’— a romanticized version of our true, unfiltered inner voice. But our gut is just as compromised as the rest of us - shaped by years of conditioning, biases, and subconscious cues. So, when we say, “I just have a good feeling about this,” are we really trusting intuition, or are we acting on patterns we don’t even recognize?
Don’t even get me started on FOMO (Fear of Missing Out)— a little devil whispering in your ear every time a new gadget drops, a celebrity trend does the rounds, a vacation spot comes to the fore on Instagram or the more recent instance of the Coldplay concert coming to town! Are we really choosing to go on that extravagant trip, that grandiose concert, that ‘must-have’ gadget or are we subconsciously responding to an algorithmically enhanced fear that we’ll be left behind? Food for thought.
Our own brains conspire against us too. We believe we are making rational decisions when, in fact, we are falling into predictable traps.
Anchoring Effect:
Have you ever seen a product listed at Rs. 2,500, then “discounted” to Rs. 1,499, and felt like you were getting a steal? That’s the anchoring effect—our tendency to rely on the first piece of information we see, whereas in reality, the product was probably always worth Rs. 1,499 or even worse, was even available at Rs. 1,250 if you tried harder to find a better source, but instead, you think you’re getting a bargain.
Default Bias:
People rarely change the default settings on their phones – it is the default bias at work. We tend to stick with pre-set options, assuming they are the best choice. This is why companies make sure that their most profitable services are the default—because they know you’re unlikely to switch.
Illusion of Personal Preference:
A slightly related phenomenon is that of personal preferences influenced by exposure. More you hear a song, the more you like it— precisely why radio stations play the same hits on repeat. Sorry to break it to you, but your “favourite” song might just be the one you’ve been subconsciously programmed to enjoy.
While we may never achieve complete freedom from influence, we can take steps to regain some agency.
Before making a decision, pause and ask yourself: Am I choosing this, or am I being nudged? Just the act of questioning can help break the cycle of blind decision-making.
Break out of the filter bubble by engaging with perspectives that challenge your beliefs. Read news from different sources, watch documentaries outside your usual interests, and talk to people with opposing viewpoints.
Use incognito mode, clear your cookies, disable personalized recommendations, or manually search for things instead of relying on suggested content. Take control over what you consume rather than being spoon-fed.
Instead of drowning in an ocean of choices, set limits. If you’re shopping for a jacket, pick three options and stick to them. If you’re choosing a movie, decide within five minutes. Constraints force clarity. Reduce unnecessary choices in daily life. Many successful people, including Steve Jobs and Mark Zuckerberg, famously wore the same outfit every day to eliminate trivial decisions and save mental energy for bigger things.
Instead of always choosing what’s familiar, try something completely outside your comfort zone. Pick a random book, visit a country you never considered, or eat at a restaurant without checking reviews. You might just find something you genuinely love without being nudged into it.
So, are we truly free? Not entirely. Our choices are shaped by digital algorithms, social expectations, and subconscious biases more than we care to admit. But recognizing these influences is the first step toward reclaiming control. True freedom isn’t about having infinite choices—it’s about making decisions with awareness and intent.
We may never fully escape the illusion of choice, but with a little conscious effort, we can at least choose how much we let it control us.
Comments